5 Youngstown Restaurants to Impress Your Valentine

5 Youngstown Restaurants to Impress Your Valentine

We know how it is…you want to treat your Valentine to the dinner they deserve but you’re not sure where to go. 

 We’re here to help! Treat your partner to something different this Valentine’s Day and try out one of these 5 amazing restaurant options close to home.  

  1. Homestead Kitchen and Cocktails 
    163 Town Center Ave. Columbiana
    Kitchen and Cocktails

Located in Columbiana’s Firestone farms, Homestead Kitchen and Cocktails provides a modern menu, beautiful cocktails, and a wonderful, cozy atmosphere. 

We recommend the Grazing Board and the Chicken Alouette. They also offer brunch!  

2.  Magic Tree Pub and Eatery
7463 South Ave, Youngstown

If you want more of a relaxed vibe, The Magic Tree is your place! They have a large menu featuring modern options and classics. They offer a huge beer and cocktail selection as well.  

We recommend the Twisted Time Pretzel (1lb of house made soft pretzel with your choice of dips) or any of their delicious burger options. 

3. Cafe 422
4422 Youngstown Rd, SE, Warren
8586 South Ave. Boardman


Café 422 is a local favorite. Cozy atmosphere, great drinks, and a classic menu sure to have some of your favorites! Everything from pasta dishes to a good steak, you can find here.  

We recommend the Blu Cheese Crusted Sirloin or The South Avenue brick oven pizza. They also offer brunch!  

4. Bistro 1907
44 Federal Plaza East, Youngstown

Located in the Double Tree hotel in the heart of Youngstown, Bistro 1907 delivers a modern dining experience with a variety of different dishes.  

We recommend the Brown Butter Filet Mignon and their Bloody Mary’s are over the top! They also offer brunch.  

5. Aqua Pazzo
492 McClurg Road (off South Avenue) Boardman

If you’re trying to impress, make a reservation for the patio at Aqua Pazzo. This restaurant has quickly become one of Youngstown’s favorites with their amazing menu filled with homemade pasta dishes and much more!  

We recommend any of the pasta dishes, especially the Spaghetti Pomodoro. Make sure to try the Warm Butter Cake for dessert!  

Where’s your favorite restaurant to take a date in Youngstown? Comment below and let us know!

A little more about The Agent Insurance Services…

The Agent Insurance Services is a full-service independent insurance agency. This allows us the ability to offer a full range of protection such as home and auto insurance, commercial insurance, and life insurance to all of our clients. To put it simply, we make sure our clients have the same coverages we have. Why would you want anything less? Our exceptional team of “Protection Advisors” offers professional advice and service you can afford. Call us and tell us what’s important to you. We’ll do the rest.

Scroll to Top